Sunday, January 25, 2009

Pursuit of Happyness

Thought I saw that movie already. Remembered bits and pieces and the overall story. Watched it tonight. Most of it was new. Did I see a preview? No, I remembered too much for a preview. Finally figured I must have seen it on an airplane, rummy from lack of sleep, hurtling through the night a few miles above the Pacific. Looked up from my book or laptop or catnap now and then, put on the headphones awhile, went back.

It’s an exhausting story. And the period of homelessness makes me want to fund shelters (except of course my systemic instincts kick in, damn them). I appreciated seeing Rev. Williams in his uncredited role as himself. I felt like a slacker and a slob watching the Will Smith character stay so focused in spite of adversity.

Focus is not my friend. Sometimes I feel I can barely accomplish anything anymore. Now would not be a good time to age out of my career but it wouldn’t surprise me if it happened within the next few years anyway. The younger guys care more, and are interested more in technology, and aren’t distracted by second-half yearnings to go find themselves. They have small children and thus strong protective instincts that override any individualist angst. Mine just need college funding and a place to park.

There was an instant when the director ran a convertible full of laughing yuppies past a long line of homeless men lining up outside the shelter at Glide Memorial. I feel like the paper-thin people in the convertible – except I’m not laughing. Not even smiling. I have my huge house and my convertible and occasionally the unbelievable privilege of experiencing the magic that hurtles one through the night a few miles above the Pacific just to go talk to men wearing suits. But other than the laughing part, I’m just as paper-thin as the people in that half-second scene. Just as thin and just as likely in a callow moment to ignore if not dismiss the people lining up for a warm place to sleep.

Systemic instincts. Compassion vies with practicality. Surely the discipline Nature imposed on Man in his days in the forest shouldn’t be discarded entirely. Why not? Not sure. Everyone deserves a hand without regard to why, at least sometimes. But I’ve an inarticulate instinct that insists there is no compassion in giving a man a fish every single day the rest of his life. Teach him to fish and if he won’t learn, leave him free to choose his own lessons.

I don’t know. I only know that charity without end leads to the Roman mob clamoring for their bread and circuses and pulling down and trampling the praetor who denies them this newly inalienable right. That is not the direction of a society with a future.

The main character muses that Thomas Jefferson was an artist, for proclaiming not happiness as a right, but the pursuit of happiness. A vital distinction. But apart from discussing the nature of rights, it’s also a reminder that happiness itself is fleeting, and sometimes we are only really happy when pursuing it.

5 comments:

AJ said...

But I’ve an inarticulate instinct that insists there is no compassion in giving a man a fish every single day the rest of his life. Teach him to fish and if he won’t learn, leave him free to choose his own lessons.

The problem with that is that you're not taking into consideration the whys of those in the line. You're assuming they've been taught to fish and chose not to. That they're lazy or something.

It's something alright, but it may not have anything to do with laziness. I think of my daughter now when I see the homeless. I think of a blogger I read regularly who suffers from schizophrenia. Before he was diagnosed he relieved his suffering with alcohol and became a homeless alcoholic. Had he not had a family able to pull him off the streets and give him the support he needed to live a better life (and he still can't hold down a job), he'd be on the streets still. If my daughter didn't have her family to take care of her, there's no way she'd be able to live a "normal" life. She knows how to fish, so to speak, she just can't do it on a regular basis.

Their instincts for survival might keep them alive, but will never allow them to live a decent life without help.

So why don't they get help through governmental programs, you might ask. Heh. The strain of doing all the things you need to do, the paperwork, the waiting in crowded spaces, etc., etc., is sometimes more than a mentally ill person can take. My daughter can't do it, not without someone by her side, helping her, and even then, once a panic attack hits, forget it, she has to get out of there.

You talk about how unfocused you are. "Sometimes I feel I can barely accomplish anything anymore." Imagine feeling that without the ability to make yourself focus when you absolutely must, an ability you still retain, obviously, because you're managing to keep it together in spite of feeling sometimes like it's all going to spin out of control (or at least like you wouldn't care if it did). Well, those with mental issues simply cannot keep it together. They do not have that ability. And so they do spin out of control, and without anyone to help them, they find themselves out on the streets, living from day to day the best they can, thankful for places that feed them freely.

Paula said...

I don't mind paying taxes to help people, but I can't deal with thinking about helping strangers directly except for giving someone a buck here and there. It's just too overwhelming, and, like you Don, I barely manage to focus on the things I need to anyway. I don't know if it's the headaches or the headache meds or age or what, but I'm having a lot of trouble with ordinary routines and tasks lately. I have to make notes about everything at work because I can no longer rely on my memory. I have to be really careful before speaking so I don't ask stupid, obvious questions or screw myself up in some way. And even so, I do silly things or forget stuff and am often snarked at, especially by one guy there who uses the "Socratic method" of making others feel small. It's really upsetting, but I console myself by telling myself I'm somewhat disabled by these awful headaches and it's only because I'm so smart and meticulous to begin with that I can do the job at all. The idea of trying to change careers or even jobs-- taking classes, being tested, dealing with new people -- is so overwhelming I can't even consider it for a minute. And the notion of having any emotional energy left to think about helping others after dealing with job + family? Bwah.

Paula said...

But I feel bad about it, is what I meant to say. See, I couldn't even remember my own point!

Don said...

I understand all your points, Arleen. I too have relatives who would have nowhere if not for family. One of my oldest friends disappeared about ten years ago into homelessness and I don't even know if he's still alive. Might have been chemical / mental issues, I don't know. I'm not against helping people. My point overall is the philosophical struggle, I guess, because there are many ways to help that make matters worse. I have walked through those parts of San Francisco and my reaction is rarely "lazy bums" because I can see in their eyes there is so much more going on. Indeed, "lazy" is a ridiculous charge, considering the horrendous stress and difficulty of it. Who would choose that merely out of laziness? I know there's so much more at work. Boy am I rambling, well, I'm in a hurry, no editing today.

Jodie Kash said...

My hairdresser and I had a similar talk yesterday on the topic of college. I’d never pay for my kid to go to college but only assist as they figure out how, and strongly propose working while doing it. I’d provide the things I’d wished for during my pursuit, little extras, but things I thought would change my life in that moment - someone else to pay a $42 a month car insurance bill. A new set of safe tires for my junker, the car we removed the thermostat from so as not to overheat in summer, meaning in the winter my friends and I drove in it wrapped in the blankets kept in the truck. In Colorado.

I learned how to fish then. And even in hard times, I’ve had fish every day since. There has to be want. If you're lucky enough to have love like Arleen gives, you're already ahead of so many whose want is clouded by something else. We all have clouds to some extent.

BTW, I think we’re happy when aware of it. Even in those times when it’s far away, knowing it’s there, knowing it’ll be back, and that rush when you emerge from muck and breathe it again.

Love that you opened this dialogue.